Can't please everybody all the time
... change, change, change...
One quality of a great artist is that they
keep changing. Over the course of their life and art, they
have different periods, and they are are forever moving ahead
and trying new things. There are many examples of this in
the painters like Picasso, who actually had periods named
after him. I visited the Salvador Dali museum in Florida and
discovered that he began by copying the former masters like
Van Gogh, and did exquisite miniatures in realistic detail
before he advanced to the more unconventional surrealism which
made him a household name. Similarly, players like Miles and
Coltrane were always creating new forms, seeking new ways
to express themselves, though they also had strong foundation
in the the rudiments. Like the painter Dali, they began by
copying the earlier masters, then went ahead and blazed their
own trail. When Miles went ‘electric’, he left many of his
fans behind, and the same with Coltrane when he went ‘free’.
True artists’ march to the beat of a different drummer, and
one cannot hold them back or limit them by imposing one’s
own judgement. The fact is that if they are great, they will
keep moving forward despite what others think, and it will
take time for those ‘left behind’ so to speak, to catch up
and recognize their genius.
Much to the frustration of some artists’,
marketing executives in record companies will try and neatly
categorized music styles to fit into their marketing molds.
By naming something, you limit it, and true Art is limitless.
The
real pro's
It's interesting to hear McCoy Tyner's playing on the album
the Coltrane Quartet did with singer Johnny Hartman, and compare
it with the playing from the Live at the Village Vanguard
sessions done about the same time. Can you recognize it's
the same piano player? Make the same comparison with Elvin
Jonesa playing on those two sessions. Some people think of
him as always playing loudly, but can you hear what a great
player he is with brushes only? That's the mark of a great
artist, the ability to adapt appropriately to different musical
environments, while maintaining integrity and identity. While
usually we all have our speciality, sometimes there are players
like McCoy and Elvin who can do everything well!
Sitting
In, the emotional element
I believe a person dedicated to music loves
to play, no matter what. I believe in jamming, rehearsing,
sitting in, anything as long as it's playing. I've moved around
a lot in my life. Each time I move to a new place I would
try and find out where people were playing jazz. I'd go there,
listen, and try to sit in with the band if they would let
me. Sometimes I'd end up going to sit in with the same band
almost every night, playing for free. Here in Singapore I
was out of work for 6 months, but I played with two local
bands for free just to be able to play some in public. I encourage
sitting in on my own gig now. In the old days this was how
younger players learned from the masters, on the bandstand.
Now there are plenty of other educational programs available,
but nothing can replace going onstage to sit in with strangers,
playing in front of strangers.
People forget that there's another element to performing which
traditional practicing doesn't address. That's the human emotional
element, getting nervous, getting jealous, getting distracted.
You can practice it perfectly at home, but onstage become
nervous or distracted and forget everything. And of course
as much as I support the use of play along tapes, playing
with real people is better. Each band and rhythm section will
treat the song and harmony differently, which means the person
sitting in has to learn to hear and adjust to what the band
is doing if he wants to fit in and sound good. Difficult to
practice that at home.
Since I've been in Asia I discovered that
people here don't sit in so readily even if they have the
opportunity. Generally speaking making money seems to be the
most important thing, so some don't like to play unless they're
paid. Then shyness is another reason people don't sit in so
readily here. Before I had the opportunity to work this regularly,
I really missed the jam sessions I used to have in the States.
Players would think nothing of driving for an hour just to
get together to play informally, even though there was no
specific gig to rehearse for. The thing is, you improve at
what you do the most of. If you want to be a better player,
play as much as possible, even if it's for free.
Personal
preferences
Usually, even though
they may be versatile, there is one particular style most
players really excel at. So far for me, that style is mainstream
jazz, improvising lines on standard changes at a medium swing
tempo, in a trio setting. While my playing direction may change
in the future, I’ll always be comfortable in that idiom.
Someone asked me recently why didn’t I play
pop-rock even though I like some of it and could make more
money. The reason is, that I’d be bored with the music. It
was the enhanced harmonic possibilities of jazz which first
attracted me. Jazz is more challenging, and rewarding for
my mind, if not my pocketbook.
I
hope my music makes you think, draws you in, even challenging
you occasionally. But I do appreciate music which induces
a relaxed mood in the listener, and this has been said of
my music. I hope there is a subtleness to my playing which
gives the listener the option of listening closely or just
relaxing, allowing the music to help create or change a mood.
This kind of playing is different from the kind of music which
hits you over the head or is ‘in your face’ so to speak. Perhaps
it can be compared to a conversation. If someone is speaking
slowly and calmly they stand a better chance of being listened
to than if they are preaching or screaming in order to prove
their point.
I believe if one does listen closely to my
music, they will find it has a lot of depth and sophistication
to offer.
My
most important view
In the end, no matter what your opinions and
preferences are, there’s room for everybody! So it’s best
to put judgement aside and appreciate the diversity and abundance
of this world. Have fun with music! It needn’t be so serious.
If you are a parent and your child wants
to play an instrument, please don’t give him the idea that
he must be great or it’s not worth it. Try not to discourage
or set unreasonable expectations. If he is meant to play it
will come naturally, and if not, let him at least have fun
with music so he learns to appreciate it.
If you are a corporate executive and want
to play guitar for fun, don’t let the fact that you’ll never
be a professional stop you from trying. (I’ve met plenty of
those!) The fact is, music is for everybody and anyone can
do it! It’s not true that some people have it and some don’t.
We all have It, but of course we’re not all meant to be professionals.
That means, for some of us, it’s quite all right to play or
sing solely for fun, without judgement.
Music, like all of God’s gifts, is to be
enjoyed and shared by all. It is not separate from life, it
is life.